On the surface, a law to make people spay or neuter pets that aren’t used for breeding seems like a simple way to reduce the pet overpopulation problem. However, controversy over one such law in South Australia shows this approach may not be as effective as previously thought.
The new law will require all pets to be neutered and microchipped, although it allows exceptions for working dogs and breeding animals, as well as animals given a health waiver by a veterinarian. While this kind of law is still uncommon, similar regulations are gaining popularity throughout the world. Proponents argue that forcing owners to spay or neuter their pets prevents accidental litters that contribute significantly to the pet overpopulation problem.
Opponents of these laws point out that many animals have caring owners who are unable to comply, such as elderly people on a fixed income or other low-income owners.
In addition, many cats fall into a gray area of ownership. These community cats typically spend time in one neighborhood and are cared for by many people. Since the South Australian law would require owners to pay for their pets to be neutered and microchipped before they can go home, opponents fear it will discourage people from picking up these community cats. This typically results in the animal being euthanized. Instead, they suggest focusing more on education, low-cost spay and neuter clinics, and trap-and-release programs for feral cats.
While this law is more strict than many, some places in the United States have similar ones. Only a handful of cities have adopted strict mandatory spay and neuter laws, and states have varying levels of regulation. Many prominent rescue groups, such as the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, don’t support mandatory spay and neuter laws. While there is a great deal of debate about laws that require spaying and neutering, there’s no question that preventing accidental breeding is an important part of controlling pet overpopulation. Learn how scientists are working to create a less invasive way to prevent stray animals from reproducing.
Help Rescue Animals
Provide food and vital supplies to shelter pets at The Animal Rescue Site for free! →